Skip to main content

Thank You 500,000 readers

Cruise - PULLMANTUR ceases CROISIÈRES DE FRANCE a Conundrum or Fait accompli?


CDF is a 100% subsidiary of PULMANTUR and was catering the French cruise market with French styled and with French cuisine offering cruises. 
by Earl of Cruise

HORIZON of CROISIÈRES DE FRANCE - courtesy CROISIÈRES DE FRANCE

You can´t serve a French anything else than French cuisine, as good quality food is one of the most essential needs for French. When money saving is needed the last will be food in France!
CDF reported an average of 100,000 cruisers on board their ships HORIZON and ZENITH. CDF was in 3rd place in the French cruise market after COSTA (CARNIVAL subsidiary) and MSC (Italian, based in Switzerland). Both are surprisingly are everything but not French. Their food is acceptable Mediterranean. And the cruises are cheap.
When once, 2008, sailing on board the BLEU DE FRANCE, ex EUROPA V, 1991, now SAGA´s SAPPHIRE, I was amazed by the cusine and the really French atmosphere on board the former German vessel, who´s heritage was still to be seen. Back then I never ate that good on board a cruise vessel as on BLEU DE FRANCE who´s kitchen was organized by Françis Lévêuque who was then running the Michelin rated LE MARCHÉ in Paris, now he is cocking in the "Chez Lévêque". The last time that I ate that good was on board FRANCE.

ZENITH of CROISIÈRES DE FRANCE - courtesy CROISIÈRES DE FRANCE

But I heard too back then that the Spanish PULLMANTUR never really understood what the French really wished. So the first CEO of CDF told me in an interview, when he explained to me his plans or ideas with the BLEU DE FRENCE which was to upgrade her to the former standard when she was he EUROPA. He was removed by a guy that was more akting to the whims of PULLMANTUR and ROYAL CARIBBEAN, the mother company of the Spanish tour operator.
With the financial crisis of 2007 the Spanish cruise market nearly perished and PULLLMANTUR got in real trouble, as the winter season sailings in South American waters hadn´t been that successful in the end. The old ROYAL CARIBBEAN  vessels had been send to PULLMANTUR for further deployment, or end use. And revenues came from France. This I got to learn from a PULLMANTUR lady in confidence.
Prior both companies tried to get a foot into the French market on their own, but never had been successful - no French language and cuisine on board the vessels. And they had the wrong drapeau at their sterns.

BLEU DE FRANCE in Palermo - Source: Wikipedia

The BLEU DE FRANCE, homeported in La Valetta, Malta, was an imediate success in the French market and in the first year CDF sailed on BLEU DE FRANCE 35,000 French passengers across the Mediterranean and Caribbean Seas. The formers CEO wish was a similar sized vessel to accompany the BLEU DE FRANCE.

Earl of Cruise in front of BLEU DE FRANCE in Ajaccio 2008 - own picture

Back then the adverts and film ad´s had been very stylish and reflected a modern styled not too luxurious atmosphere. The actual advert similarities reflect a reality show atmosphere of no class.

CDF Mediterranean Cruise on youtube, unfortunately I no longer posses the original video from 2008 of CDF

SAGA SAPPHIRE, ex BLEU DE FRANCE, ex HOLIDAY DREAM, ex MAGASTAR SRIES, ex EUROPA, 1991 - Source:Wikipedia

When SAGA was in need of a new second hand vessel, the BLEU DE FRANCE was sold, and the ZENITH entered with minimal changes as the new CDF vessel the market. The passenger numbers still rose and the HORIZON went into the French market too. While PULLMANTUR sold its no longer market compatible vessels for scrap. Amoung them the OCEANIC. To me it locked like squeezing out the last drop of the RCI vessels. With numbers declining in Spain, the French market was a source of funds for PULLMANTUR as the subsidiaries from ROYAL CARIBBEAN. Finally the Spanish investment company SPRINGWATER situated in Switzerland, Nyon, purchased a 51% stake in PULLMANTUR from ROYAL CARIBBEAN, but without the vessels, which stayed in possession of ROYAL CARIBBEAN and had to be chartered by PULLMANTUR. For PULLMANTUR a new CEO was found with RICHARD VOGEL, who luckily was on the right place in the hotel operation of the Rahe family, amoung them the LOUIS C. JACOB (5star luxury) situated on the Elbchaussee. When Mr. Rahe inaugurated the AIDA brand in the 90s and later Mr. Vogel changed to TUI CRUISES, after bidding battle for P&O which CARNIVAL did win, as the first CEO of the joint venture of ROYAL CARIBBEAN and TUI GROUP. AIDA once started as a brand for the tour and cruise operator SEETOURS, owned by the Rahe family, which is still owning the Hotel and did purchase in 1991 the GDR fleet, DEUTSCHE SEEREEDEREI, amoung them the then ARCONA, now in the fleet of SAGA. The following, 2nd, ARCONA is now with Mr. Katsoufis cruise line: Cruise & Maritime Voyages and the German TRANSOCEAN Kreuzfahrten.

I am not the only one wondering "whether abandoning the French concept which had made CDF successful is more a ‘political’ move by RCI, particularly since “considering how nationalistic the French tend to be”, why should our Gaelic cousins wish to cruise Spanish-style….or Italian for that matter?"
Alan Dumelow

ASTORIA sailing in charter for RIVAGES DU MONDE - courtesy RIVAGES DU MONDE


CDF’s departure leaves Paris-based RIVAGES DU MONDE as the only company offering French-based cruise options on the chartered vintage Astoria which, amazingly, in September/October 2017, has two transatlantic cruises including one to the Amazon and Caribbean. Other than that, French-based PLEIN CAP are marketing cruises on the German FTI BERLIN and Plantours’ HAMBURG, from which latter company PLEIN CAP had (in the past) chartered in the former VISTAMAR for French-biased cruises. VISTAMAR is now sailing for the Lebanese shipowner Abu Mehri. There is also, of course, the French company PONANT - but they now primarily market to an International (most US American) clientele and, besides, their prices are out of reach of most French - catering the 5star expedition market.

LE BOREAL of PONANT, flying the drapeau Francais - courtesy PONANT


LESVOYAGES DE TMR : Croisieres & Tour du Monde is owning this brand name now.

Back to not only my wondering - Mr. Vogel is not known as French friendly and the SPRINGWATER INVESTMENT is divided in a Spanish, Swiss, French and Luxemburg branch. And I learned from a board member that Luxemburg and Spain had been involved in the purchase deal. The founder of SPRINGWATER, in 2002, is Mr. Martin Gruschka. So saving the fur of the Spanish investment seems to be the driving factor for ceasing CROISIÈRES DE FRANCE, despite success.

This will bring a backlash into the French cruise market for years to come - new investors will have to fight for acceptance and must show confidence and standing in the French market. The ceasing of successful CDF will make it hard, if not impossible, for new cruise ventures. Listening to bean counting MBA´s may be not a good move.


Reiseberichte - CROISIÈRE DE FRANCE, La France sur la mer

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

HISTORY - Traveling with airliner LZ 129 HINDENBURG was the most luxurious airtravel

The real airliner LZ 129 HINDENBURG enabled the most luxurious airtravel for decades. Imagine, gliding through the air while the landscape or the sea below can be seen ... LZ 129 HINDENBURG marks the climax of airship construction. On May 6, 1937, the story of civilian airship ended in a tragedy. In Lakehurst, New Jersey, the largest flying object and has been with the similar sized LZ 130 GRAF ZEPPELIN II the most luxurious of all time. How this came about can be reconstructed logically, a series of fatal physics concatenations . The airship LZ 129 HINDENBURG marks the climax of airship construction. It was in its time the fastest and most exclusive traveling object between Europe and America. The challenges of the construction of the giant of the heaven were immense. by Earl of Cruise LZ 129 HINDENBURG, 1936, in Lakehurst - digital copy of a coloured cover photo, originally by Bill Schneider, published in Dan Grossman´s book ` ZEPPELIN HINDENBURG: AN ILLUSTRATED HI...

HISTORY - ss LA BOURGOGNE - Women and Children last

What had happend on sinking LA BOURGOGNE? Why had been so few women and children been rescued ? by João Martins , editing by Earl of Cruise ss LA BOURGOGNE - editors collection From our viewpoint of today we see this disaster of ss LA BOURGOGNE as one of egoism and the right of the stronger, with no "heroism", or stepping back for the weak to be saved. And we blame the crew for not doing their duty ... Are we allowed to judge? Are we allowed to chide? Are we alowed to claime it as typical ... for the seamanship of France - I have heard and read so! - ?  No, we have not been on board.  This tragedy is not the place to be chauvinistic! And looking in todays world we see a lot of chauvinism again and egoism! The ss LA BOURGOGNE was a 7,395 GRT French ocean liner built by the FCM in Toulon for the Transatlatic mail and passenger service of Cie. Gle. TRANSATLANTIQUE and completed in 1886. She was an iron and steel construction, 150 metres long, had two funnels an...

Heritage - Boabdil the last Muslim King in Spain

Abu `Abd All āh Mohammed XII, the Spanish name him Boabdil, is the last Muslim king in Spain and at the very end of a 700 year lasting, most fruitful realm. Based on original research, and drawing attention to the connections between the medieval Moorish king Boabdil , actually Abu `Abd All āh Mohammed XII, and current social and political concerns in Europe today, Cambridge academic Elizabeth Drayson presents the first full account in any language of the Moorish sultan of Granada, and head of the Nasrid dynasty. As historian I am fascinated by the once liberal cultur of al-Ándalus . It was once a thriving center of cultural exchange between christian Europe and the Arabian world and knowledge, that Arabian cientists, doctors, astronomers, historians and intelectuals saved from ancient times and developed further on. by Earl of Cruise Especially the knowledge and developments in navigation, shipbuilding and rigging, made it possible for the comming age of discovery. As well the...

Expedition Cruises - ULSTEIN© embarks on expedition cruise market

Embarking on the expedition cruise market and following the ULSTEIN © motto - "Stay different" by Earl of Cruise "Stay different." The niche of ULSTEIN , their credo, even when embarking in the expedition cruise market. Years ago, attending the SMM in Hamburg, a friend of mine and me got an idea, when seeing the X-Bow of the ULSTEIN models of Offshore vessels , " Couldn´t this be the right bow for expedition cruise vessels? "  We got into a heated discussion. Me pro, he contra. In his opinion it was too far off from the mainstream what a cruise passenger is expecting from the design of his cruise or expedition ship.  We had been discussing too the up-and-down discussed freak wave casualties. Stay different." The niche of ULSTEIN ©, explorer cruise vessel with X-Bow - courtesy © ULSTEIN "Stay different." The niche of ULSTEIN © , explorer cruise vessel with X-Bow - courtesy © ULSTEIN The expedition cruise market had...

F&B, Style - A Beautiful Jug, a Cup and a Bucket

About a jug, a cup, a champagne bucket. by Richard Arebalo for the Texas Wine and Food Foundation editing by Earl of Cruise I’ve collected antique silver for many years, but lately the pace has accelerated and the size of the collection has grown the more I am inspired by the beautiful scenes in Downton Abbey. While watching my guilty pleasure, I am particularly drawn to the details of preparing, presenting and serving the food and wine. In every kitchen scene depicting frantic food preparation, there is always a gallery of beautiful copper pots and dessert molds in the background. In the dining room, be it breakfast or dinner, table settings and service pieces are stunning and, thanks to the show’s historical advisor, Alastair Bruce, meticulously accurate for the period. top and below, Tastevin - courtesy TEXAS WINE & FOOD I can definitely imagine seeing Mr. Carson, the butler, using a couple of my recent wine-related purchases--an Edwardian wine ewer fr...

Ocean Liners in Movies or Films at Sea (updated Nov 2017)

For liners and the shipping companies movies and films had been a top marketing tool Movies or Films and liners at sea, had been intriguing me since I have read about in my youth in LUXUSLINER - BILDER EINER GROSSEN ZEIT by Lee Server ( THE GOLDEN AGE OF OCEAN LINERS ). But earlier, mot only since my first crossing, I was keen watching movies with liners in it, and disapointed, which was an understatement, when I realized the films have been made in a set ashore in some movie "factory". That was after my first crossing.   by Earl of Cruise an essay in progress `Sabrina´, Humphrey Bogart in the office, while LIBERTÉ is sailing out of New York harbor - screenshot Ocean liners, especially those of the luxury category, had been the location of dramas, love stories, thrillers, suspense and catastrophies sinde film was born, or nearly. In this list, the most descriptions are taken from Wikipedia, as I guess no one can expect having seen all these films ... otherwise I w...

ss NORMANDIE 1935-1942 XIII - Le NORMANDIE the great triumph and tragic end of the greatest ship of France

NORMANDIE at sea - courtsey coloured by Daryl LeBlanc Le NORMANDIE , the greates ship of France, was a great triumph for the French industry, economy the most gracious ambassador of France - a symbol of cultur and Savoir de Vivre. NORMANDIE never surppassed by any liner. But whom the gods love, they beat him to a tragic ending. In case of NORMANDIE the gods let do their dirty job by careless, ignorant and arrogant US Navy officials and their sub contractors.   by Earl of Cruise   NORMANDIE had 4 years of living and the chance to bring Glitz, Glamour and Luster into a world that was just in front of an abyss since October 1929. Sailing with NORMANDIE , created to cater primarily the First Clas clientele, and enjoying life on board seems to me today, as a Dance on the Volcano, that errupted in 1939. Longitudinal cutaway of PARIS - own collection copy from a CGT broshure ÎLE DE FRANCE , Cie Gle TRANSATLANTIQUE provoking ART DÉCO liner - own collection  ...

Ships of State - BREMEN the shocking modern German Greyhound

When BREMEN , the first of the two, the world shocking last German Greyhounds , and ` Ships of State ´, was introduced in 1929 - BREMEN had provoking radical new streamlined lines and broke with any traditions. When asking todays public: what is a typical liner, BREMEN is named among the first five. Only ten years after the Versailles Peace Treaty , with 20,000,000,000,000.00 Goldmark anual reparations for the next 58 years, an occupation of the Ruhrgebiet , a raging inflation till 1923 (then introduction of the Rentenmark ), the resurging Germany and NORDDEUTSCHER LLOYD back at the top again. And BREMEN and EUROPA had been financed private! Bank loans from German and US American banks, plus the liberation of frozen LLOYD capital from pre WWI. by Earl of Cruise BREMEN, in her first years with the squat funnels - courtesy coloured by Daryl LeBlanc The difference to EUROPA are the paired windows in the front of the promenade deck and the big ventilators, the last remains o...

Cruise Newbuilts - CELEBRITY EDGE Class

The CELEBRITY EDGE is the first of a class of five new ships for CELEBRITY after nearly a decade. With 117,000 GT the EDGE class ships are slightly maller than the SOLSTICE class , 121,000 GT and 2,852 pax. All five ships are being built at STX in France. The second ship, CELEBRITY BEYOND, is scheduled to debut in spring 2020. The two yet-unnamed ships will sail in fall 2021 and spring 2022. They will have similar imaginative names I guess ... by Earl of Cruise CELEBRITY EDGE, X shaped funnel with the logo looking forward, and the Magic Carpet, looking outbalanced is a nice description for that gimmick feature - Rendering courtsey CELEBRITY CRUISES A few weeks ago ROYAL CARIBBEAN CRUISES ceo Richard Fain and CELEBRITY CRUISES ceo Lisa Lutoff-Perlo announced in Fort Lauderdale details of the long-mooted 117,000-ton 2,900-berth EDGE class ships that will, among other things, bring balconies indoors as an integral part of the stateroom. It is said this new $5 Billion class o...

Deluxe - The Best Luxury Cruise Ships

Each year, and each magazine is printing or posting in the web their list of the 10 Best Luxury Cruise Ships. So do I now, with my view about their luxury ... Latest with the press releases at ITB in Berlin, we know, there is a stronger demand for luxury / luxurious cruises.   by Earl of Cruise SILVER EXPLORER, the former PRINCE ALBERT II, ex WORLD DISCOVERER of SOCIETY EXPEDITIONS, she was the expedition cruise vessels for SILVERSEA - Source: Wikipedia ( original seize ) Most it is a copy paste story, as all the time the same ships/cruise companies appear ... and sometime the described vessels are are nothing else than mass market ships, with an added first class space for the "wanna-be´s" in the mass market. So the YACHT CLUB of MSC, the CLOUD 9 at CARNIVAL, the QUEENS GRILL at CUNARD, etc. And this "luxury" areas are promoted as the top of the notch ... still a cramped affair on a high density vessel. Compared to the quarters of the emigrants that had ...