Heritage - Innovation and CUNARD?

CUNARD innovative?
by Earl of Cruise

In a CUNARD LINE promotion video for the renovation of QUEEN MARY 2, a lady from the PR department declared "Cunard was allways, since its beginning, ahead of time and innovative" ... I did remember `TRANSATLANTIC´, written by Stephen Fox, a freelance historian.

He wrote a lively, fair minded social and technological history of the transatlantic shipping, which that lady should have read ... if not more

CUNARD LINE, originaly the BRITISH & NORTH AMERICAN ROYAL MAIL STEAMPACKET COMPANY (1839), with its founding partners Samuel Cunard, Scot James Macqueen, James Donaldson, George Burns and David Mac Iver had to be strickt in following the regulations, set by the Admirality of Great Britain.

rms BRITANNIA - courtesy of JFK World

In those days the Admirality was responsible for the Royal Mail contracts, and required to follow their regulations for the contrated mail partners.

Such a mail contract was a subsidiary, neccessary for running steamship lines in those days. The passengers and the "normal" freight had been an add on. The contract required wodden hull paddle steamers. It was in the Admiralities mind that a wodden ship is the best for the motion in and on the seas. Later the Admirality changed "it´s mind" to iron hull, but did stick to the paddle wheels, while competitors used screw driven ships. PERSIA (1856) and SCOTIA (1861) are the best example for the conservative standing of the Admiralities requirements. Besides the CUNARD hulls have been wider than those of the competitors. And the steam engines of CUNARD have not been the latest in technology.

rms PERSIA - source: Wikipedia

Innovations in design, interior, for the hull or mashinery hadn´t been favored by CUNARD, or the Admirality.

They could claim for security, no loss of live at sea since the sinking of LUSITANIA and being on time, as for the contract was required.

rms MAURETANIA in her late years in cruise livery - © coloured by Daryl LeBlanc

Their first and for long the only innovation was the use of turbine power in CARONIA, LUSITANIA and MAURETANIA. But they have second, as the ALLAN LINE had their turbine steamers prior to CUNARD LINE. And the use of turbines has been sicated by the funds and the mail contract CUNARD signed to build the competitors to the German greyhounds.

The innovation of interior design was never a point in the phylosophy of CUNARD. Even the service was lacking. One point in the success of COMPAGNIE GÉNÉRALE TRANSATLANTIQUE - especially the food, NORDDEUTSCHER LLOYD, HAPAG, and WHITE STAR LINE. Food and service had been apropriate but not good. Only if competitors occured, as the COLLINS LINE and WHITE STAR LINE, CUNARD improved a bit, and went to "normal" when the competition was over (especially after COLLINS LINE bancrupcy).

The vessels interior was generally linited to the space the construction allowed. The limits have been the size, the position of mashinery and shots (water tight compartments). Public rooms and cabins had to follow these firsts.

When NORDDEUTSCHER LLOYD sent the KAISERWILHELM DER GROSSE to sea they offered a new luxury of public space, which wasn´t followed in any new constructed vessel in Great Britain. Dining rooms stayed one floor rooms since the AQUITANIA. The staircases became grand, yes, but had been a single in space.

ss KAISER WILHELM DER GROSSE, framed cutaway copy - own collection

Inbetween the 2nd and 3rd funnel the innovative location of the main dining room is visible

And with the divided funnel casings of VATERLAND - later LEVIATHAN and BISMARCK - later MAJESTIC, was another "new" in interior design at sea.

The general interior design on ships followed examples from ashore. The British vessels have been reflections of Edwardian, Georgian or Elizabethen interiors. The travelling public took it as given. CUNARD did stick to his British design, but used too international interior architects, as the international travellers did demand. Therefore international renowned architects and artisans have been contracted. Even those who worked for German lines. Only from Germany came the attempt for establishing the Jungendstil and Wiener Sezession. GEORGE WASHINGTON and KAISERIN AUGUSTE VICTORIA - later EMPRESS OF SCOTLAND, are bright and airy examples for. And from France the Art Nouveaux as in PARIS. Even when the Ocean Liner Design was hip in design CUNARD stayed conservative. Same with the exterior design as seen in EMPRESS OF BRITAIN (CANADIAN PACIFIC) and QUEEN MARY and imrpoved in QUEEN ELIZABETH. QUEEN MARY has been an advanced MAURETANIA or AQUITANIA.

rns QUEEN MARY - © coloured by Daryl LeBlanc

CUNARD has been beaten in design again by the German BREMEN and EUROPA, but the most by NORMANDIE and her all over design, interior and exterior. And in technology as well.

Compared to BREMEN, EUROPA and NORMANDIE CUNARD sailed with "celtic stone age" design and technology.

ts BREMEN in 1929 - own collection

ss NORMANDIE steaming through calm and sunny sea, aerial photography taken from a greeting plane on her inaugural sailing to New York in 1935
© coloured by Daryl LeBlanc

After WWII there was no longer a real competitor in the North Atlantic left. Again the international clientele lacked the German service, but had in ÎLE DE FRANCE and later LIBERTÉ the French "Savoir Vivre". FRENCH LINE advertized with the "Longest Gangplank to France".

CUNARD had over the time wonderful vessels. Sturdy and solid. But the ships stayed conservative in their all over design. And after WWII resting in pre war. So for the CARONIA (1948) - the millionaires ship or The Green Goddess, SAXONIA, IVERNIA, CARINTHIA and SYLVANIA (1956/57). Modern design as seen in KUNGSHOLM (1953) and GRIPSHOLM (1957), OSLOFJORD (1949) and BERGENSFJORD (1956) wasn´t on the helm. They gave Scandinavian design to the seafaring public.

It changed really dramatically with the inauguration of QUEEN ELIZABETH 2 in 1969 and shocked the British CUNARD clientle to the core. The futuristic 60ties and early 70ties design interior and the single funnel nearly aft was a new and a first for CUNARD to be "avant garde" ...

rns QUEEN ELIZABETH 2 in her first appearance - own collection

Claiming CUNARD as trendsetter in any way of design and technology is not correct. And a CUNARD PR lady or man should have made her/his homework, and should have read minmum TRANSATLANTIC of Stephen Fox, avoiding babbling the false only for publicity reasons ...
It is easier believing the fals facts than in the truth ... and repeatedly telling the false makes it into the truth ... ingraining it ... and truth is lost!

Comments

Ocean Liners in Movies or Films at Sea (updated Nov 2017)

For liners and the shipping companies movies and films had been a top marketing tool Movies or Films and liners at sea, had been intriguing me since I have read about in my youth in LUXUSLINER - BILDER EINER GROSSEN ZEIT by Lee Server ( THE GOLDEN AGE OF OCEAN LINERS ). But earlier, mot only since my first crossing, I was keen watching movies with liners in it, and disapointed, which was an understatement, when I realized the films have been made in a set ashore in some movie "factory". That was after my first crossing. by Earl of Cruise an essay in progress `Sabrina´, Humphrey Bogart in the office, while LIBERTÉ is sailing out of New York harbor - screenshot Ocean liners, especially those of the luxury category, had been the location of dramas, love stories, thrillers, suspense and catastrophies sinde film was born, or nearly. In this list, the most descriptions are taken from Wikipedia, as I guess no one can expect having seen all these films ... otherwise I w...

Liners - Can classic ocean liners make a comeback

Classic ocean liners, crossing the oceans, had been for long time the only way to cross the seas. A comeback of ocean liners for real? When in 2010 the Islandic volcano Eyjafjallajökull did errupt, and all flights that would come near his ash-clouds had to be cancelled, people had been trapped on each side of the pond ... And immidiately all available cabins on containerships had been booked, cruise vessels sailing either to the Americas or Europe had been flodded by desperate travellers to get to their destination ... Going by ship was in those days the only way to cross. It did show a certain, but temporary neccessity of liner traffic. But unfortunately we did not have any longer a frequent crossing possibility by ship - Transatlantic liners, liners per se had gone, gone with the wind of history and technical progress in air flight. Is an ocean liner comeback possible? by Earl of Cruise rms QUEEN ELIZABETH 2 © Beken - own collection, copy from a postcard CUNARD held the ...

HISTORY - HAMBURG the Space Ship

HAMBURG , HANSEATIC, stared as Britannic in ` Juggernaught ´, MAXIM GORKIY nicknamed Space Ship ts HAMBURG in DEUTSCHE ATLANTIK LINE colours - own collection, copy from a promotion broschure When HAMBURG was introduced a TV show aired with adventures in the space, their ship was the Enterprise which had a saucer shaped main section and three main arm like pillars holding the saucer as well the two engin sections. by Earl of Cruise The funnel of HAMBURG had quite a resemblance to that particular TV airship, created for STAR TREK by Gene Roddenberry . Axel Bitsch Christensen in front of the ts HAMBURG funnel - own collection, photo originaly owned by Anders Bitsch Christensen This funnel, as controversial it is and was, was only one reason why HAMBURG was nicknamed the Space Ship, but there was another reason, a real one, HAMBURG was the most spacious passenger shipp of her days. Constructing ts HAMBURG from 1966 till 1969 - own collection, copy from my bo...

ss NORMANDIE 1935 - 1942 IX

s s / te NORMANDIE starting from cold Owners: COMPAGNIE GÉNÉRALE TRANSATLANTIQUE BUILDERS: PENH Ö ET, St. Nazaire, France by Stephen Carey © , editing by Earl of Cruise This document is almost exclusively about the engineering aspects of NORMANDIE , mainly on how to start her up from cold. If you are looking for photos of the passenger spaces, there is a plethora of them on the web, in Facebook groups - Admirers of the ss Normandie , ss Normandie photographic file , The French Ocean Liners / Les Paquebots Fran ç ais , ss Normandie , GREAT LINERS OF THE PAST & PRESENT , and others, Pinterest and in articles about NORMANDIE here in the blog, please see at the end of the article. Using "ss" for NORMANDIE is quite incorrect, as NORMANDIE was a Turbo Electric vessel and not a steamship, therefore NORMANDIE should be adressed as "te". by Earl of Cruise te / ss NORMANDIE berthed in Le Havre, Gare Maritime May 29th, 1935 - colouring courtesy ...

Heritage - Voyage of the Damned on St.LOUIS

St.LOUIS sailed in May 1939 with Jewish refugees to Cuba, a voyage known today as the VOAYAGE of the DAMNED. On May 13, 1939, the German liner St.LOUIS sailed from Hamburg, Germany, for Havana, Cuba. On the voyage were 937 passengers. Almost all were Jews fleeing from the Third Reich. Most were German citizens, some were from eastern Europe, and a few were officially "stateless". Basicly the journey was a fraud, set up by sinister Propaganda Minister Josef Goebbels and his staff, to showcase nobody is interested in wanting Jews among them ... and till a seeming bitter end the free countries played in the Nazis directed game as they wished ... by Earl of Cruise based on Holocaust Ecyclopedia´s article St.LOUIS, sister ship of MILWAUKEE, were motorships of HAMBURG AMERIKA LINIE which served on different lines for HAPAG, as well on cruises - collection Earl of Cruise The majority of the Jewish passengers had applied for Cuba tourist visas and US immigration vi...

The modern Black Gang

Stewardesses and Stewards are the modern " BlackGang " by Earl of Cruise Stokers on board USS MASSACHUSETS - source Wikipedia The men working in the bowels of the steamers had been named Black Gang. these where those men with the hardest labour - bringing the coal form the bunkers to the furnasses and filling them. This ardous labour became obsolete, when the steamer and turbine furnasses became oil fired - cleaner, fewer men and no longer heat and coal dust drenched air. The living conditions, when free from their shifts, had been similar ardous - cramped sleeping rooms, no light and less air, and few washing rooms and toilets. The loan was less than acceptable. Despite some some first class travellers made their way in these aereas, as into third class, to "slum a bit", for whatever their reasons may have been, or tipping the men of the Black Gang for harder work making a fast voyage. DAS TOTENSCHIFF , B. Traven, bying , In 1959 it was adapted int...

HISTORY - ss LA BOURGOGNE - Women and Children last

What had happend on sinking LA BOURGOGNE? Why had been so few women and children been rescued ? by João Martins , editing by Earl of Cruise ss LA BOURGOGNE - editors collection From our viewpoint of today we see this disaster of ss LA BOURGOGNE as one of egoism and the right of the stronger, with no "heroism", or stepping back for the weak to be saved. And we blame the crew for not doing their duty ... Are we allowed to judge? Are we allowed to chide? Are we alowed to claime it as typical ... for the seamanship of France - I have heard and read so! - ? No, we have not been on board. This tragedy is not the place to be chauvinistic! And looking in todays world we see a lot of chauvinism again and egoism! The ss LA BOURGOGNE was a 7,395 GRT French ocean liner built by the FCM in Toulon for the Transatlatic mail and passenger service of Cie. Gle. TRANSATLANTIQUE and completed in 1886. She was an iron and steel construction, 150 metres long, had two funnels an...

Starting rms TITANIC from cold

rms TITANIC, 1911, Cold Starting WHITES STAR LINE Ltd., Builders: HALAND & WOLFF, Belfast by Stephen Carey, engineer, editing by Earl of Cruise rms TITANIC, 1911 © Stephen Carey Table of Contents 1 Overview of machinery spaces 1.1 Boiler rooms 1.2 Coal bunkers 1.3 Propulsion engines 1.4 Electrical power generation 1.4.1 Main generating sets 1.4.2 Emergency generating sets 2 Lighting up the boilers 2.1 Steam line redundancy 3 Starting the generators 3.1 Auxiliary seawater pump and condenser 3.2 Starting an emergency gener...

HISTORY - The Royal Mail Ship TAHITI

While researching for some Tahiti and French Polynesia related articles, I came across this Wikipedia article about a small, lesser known steamship, which served as a "mail boat" in the South Pacific - rms TAHITI . editing by Earl of Cruise Beside the big liners on the main routes, especially the North Atlantic, on "side routes", which had been and are important for the international trade, we find countless numbers of ships. These smaller, unimpressive ones are the back-bones of each shipping entity. Most of these vessels had been combined passenger and freight liners - so PORT KINGSTON, later TAHITI. For its last owner the vessel sailed across the Pacific from Sydney to California and back. rms TAHITI sailing the Pacific - Source: Wikipedia TAHITI was a 7,585 ton ocean liner operated by the UNION STEAMSHIP COMPANY OF NEW ZEALAND . Built in 1904 on Clydebank by the shipbuilders ALEXANDER STEPHEN & Sons , she was named rms Port Kingston until 1911....

ss NORMANDIE 1935-1942 XIII - Le NORMANDIE the great triumph and tragic end of the greatest ship of France

NORMANDIE at sea - courtsey coloured by Daryl LeBlanc Le NORMANDIE , the greates ship of France, was a great triumph for the French industry, economy the most gracious ambassador of France - a symbol of cultur and Savoir de Vivre. NORMANDIE never surppassed by any liner. But whom the gods love, they beat him to a tragic ending. In case of NORMANDIE the gods let do their dirty job by careless, ignorant and arrogant US Navy officials and their sub contractors. by Earl of Cruise NORMANDIE had 4 years of living and the chance to bring Glitz, Glamour and Luster into a world that was just in front of an abyss since October 1929. Sailing with NORMANDIE , created to cater primarily the First Clas clientele, and enjoying life on board seems to me today, as a Dance on the Volcano, that errupted in 1939. Longitudinal cutaway of PARIS - own collection copy from a CGT broshure ÎLE DE FRANCE , Cie Gle TRANSATLANTIQUE provoking ART DÉCO liner - own collection ...

Search This Blog

Thank You 500,000 readers